A Study in Magic by Vixit

Story Title: A Study in Magic
Author Name:  Vixit
Story Url: Story Link
Content Rating: Teen
Status: Completed
Length:   47,088 words
Story Summary:  When Albus Dumbledore shows up atBaker Streetwith strange demands and baby-filled picnic baskets, Sherlock Holmes is less than thrilled. Featuring Detective!Harry, Competent!Quirrell, and the world’s only private consulting detective. No slash.

Gioia’s Rec:
This story was startlingly good.  I’ve seen other Harry Potter/Sherlock Holmes crossover fics, but never one quite like this.

The plot is far more complicated – and yet far more simple – than I had expected.  Just when I thought I had things figured out, the author would surprise me with something which was, in retrospect, quite obvious.  It felt like a true Sherlock Holmes story in that regard.

In this AU fic, an infant Harry is placed with Sherlock Holmes.  The story is written as if by Dr. Watson in many places, adding a level of authenticity to it.  Holmes’ reactions to magic and to the wizarding world are fantastic and, again, feel very true to his character.  Harry’s character is, of course, very changed in many ways thanks to his upbringing in Holmes’ household, instead of with the Dursleys.  Yet, his core self is still there, as is very evident by the end of the story, thanks to the relationships he has formed.  Nature vs. Nurture is very much a factor in understanding Harry’s role and his behavior here.

My biggest regret about this story is that the author has stated that there are no plans for a sequel to this story, which covers roughly Oct. 1981-June 1992.  However, this is such a self-contained, completely encapsulated tale, that my regrets should not imply that anything is left wanting about this fic.  Rather, I’m simply feeling selfish and want more. 😉  I suppose I shall have to be content with stalking the author’s profile page, in the hopes that Vixit’s future inspirations/story ideas coincide with my multi-fandom fic cravings.  This is definitely an author worth watching.

Please Note:  As always on this blog, the “Out-of-character behavior (Deliberate)” tag is NEVER used as a critique.  In this case, it refers specifically to the way Harry behaves different than canon!Harry, thanks to his upbringing. This is a deliberate plot point, and central to the story development.

About Gioia

I'm a wife and mother and, when not tied up with responsibilities, I read non-stop. I love to share my favorite stories with others, thus the existence of my blog.
This entry was posted in Action/Adventure, Alternate Universe, Content Rating-HP: Teen (PG-13), Crossover, Drama/Angst, Friendship/Mentorship, Gen, Harry Potter, Introspective, Mystery/Suspense, Out-of-character behavior (Deliberate), Sherlock Holmes, Spoilers for Philosopher's/Sorcerer's Stone and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to A Study in Magic by Vixit

  1. Jeyna Grace says:

    Cool.. a cross fan fic.. not bad of an idea.

  2. Pingback: A Study In Magic by Book of Changes | Gioia Recs…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s